

We finally got up the nerve to let AJ cry it out (CIO) at bedtime. I have to start with the disclaimer that before we had children, I thought I would never be cold enough to let my child cry himself/herself to sleep. Then I had a child who was a problem sleeper, and I realized that we had a responsibility to help him learn how to sleep for his own health, even if it was hard for me to do. This realization made me think of a line that I used to hear from my dad as a kid: "This is more painful for me than it is for you." As a kid, I thought that was a bunch of baloney. As a parent, I realize how true it is.
For weeks we had discussed the CIO option, with Joe being very pro-CIO and me being hesitantly interested in the alleged benefits without being ready to go through the actual cry it out part. In the back of my mind, I thought that we would discuss it with the pediatrician, buy what I considered essential supplies for the project (video nursery monitor to make sure AJ is not crying because he leg is stuck between the crib slats, giant foam finger to use to shake at Joe when crying it out didn't work, etc.), read a few more books on the subject and finally set a date on the calendar for the big night. Instead, it happened spontaneously one night when I was rocking AJ after trying to calm him for bed for two hours. As I tried to cuddle and soothe him, AJ pushed away from me with all his strength, and I realized that I was not helping him get to sleep. In fact, it seemed that whatever I was doing was intensely annoying him. So I put him in the crib, kissed him on the head, took a deep breath and took an hour-long shower to try to drown out his crying.
He cried for two hours that first night, which was actually less than I had steeled myself for. Don't get me wrong--it was still the hardest two hours of my life (even harder than childbirth), but I thought after AJ cried the entire way from Chicago to Des Moines, Iowa that crying it out would never get to the "out" part for us. The only thing that got me through it was when Joe told me to give AJ a chance to succeed on his own. It made me think that rushing in to comfort him would be a step down the slippery slope toward the mom who gets so upset when her child goes to kindergarten than she cries, making the kid upset as well instead of excited for the new experience.
The next night he cried for 45 minutes. On the third night, he went to bed without as much as a little peep. I was shocked. The third night success was especially appreciated by me, because Joe had an evening recruiting event for work that night, and I was not looking forward to enduring the crying on my own. On the fourth night, AJ was back to crying for 45 minutes. Tonight is the fifth night--we will see what it brings. I hope it is zzzs.
The pictures are of Andrew in his cute stripey hand-me-down PJs from his buddies S. and B.